Date:

Author:
Category:

Who did I Wanna Be Your Man better, the Beatles or the Rolling Stones?

Today in our article the story of the creation of the song "I Wanna Be Your Man". Who became the best performer of the hit of the 60s and what does The Beatles have to do with it? Let's find out!

The song "I Wanna Be Your Man": history of creation, best performance, covers

In the '60s, many of the bands that would later become world-famous only started their artistic rise. Such mastodons of modern rock music as The Beatles and The Rolling Stones also started their journey with the little-known simple songs that nevertheless rose to the top of the charts.

This article will talk about the song "I Wanna Be Your Man"about its interesting history of creation and its struggle for the right to be called best the singer of an early '60s hit.

The story of the song intended for Ringo Starr

The Beatles
The Beatles

In the '60s, the Beatles already had large The success of the public, although John Lennon and Paul McCartney had to experience the love of the fans. But as time went on, so did the popularity others band members Ringo Starr and George Harrison. For the former, the creative tandem of Lennon/McCartney created a song called "Boys."so that the drummer could also please the fans not only with his playing but also with his voice.

As the band's fan base grew, Ringo's songs that were not played in concert still were included into the set lists, and then one song was not enough for the drummer's fans. At that time John and Paul decided to create one more song specially for Ringo.

The idea for a new song did not come to the musicians immediately: it all started with John, who accidentally saw a phrase in a newspaper "I Wanna Be Your Man". He often picked up on such pithy lines, but this one became the centre for writing another hit song to it. Paul soon began writing the lyrics, trying to create a composition, maximally closer to Boys. The songwriting process continued until meeting The Rolling Stones.

The Liverpool Four's version was released in 1963 in late autumn on the UK version of their second album "With The Beatles". Long and painfully the band tried to record this composition. The musicians recorded about 6 different options The final step was to put the organ sound on the best version, and then the track was ready for release. The final thing was to overlay the organ sound on the best version, and then the track was ready for release.

George Harrison, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. 60-х
George Harrison, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. 60-х

Several times musicians have recorded this song for BBCfirst in 1964 and then many years later for a compilation of The Beatles' live radio broadcasts. Also, one version of the song was recorded for the "Around The Beatles.".

How did I Wanna Be Your Man end up at Rolling Stone?

The Rolling Stones. 1964
The Rolling Stones. 1964

There are several versions of how musicians "exchanged" a song with his colleagues. Paul McCartney claimed that he and John saw Mick and Keith in a taxi and asked for a lift, and the conversation revealed that the Stones were looking for a song for the single. Then the generous Beatles shared a freshly written composition, saying it wasn't finished yet.

The musicians were then invited to the studio where the Stones were recording. Paul and John played an unfinished version "I Wanna Be Your Man"Mick and Keith thought the song could be a commercial success for them. The rockers quickly agreed to use it, but they needed to completed option. Then the leaders of The Beatles withdrew, and after some time came to their colleagues already with a ready with the lyrics. This ability to quickly find the right words for a song made a lasting impression on the musicians.

The version recorded by the Stones is a bit beforethan the Beatles' version, was released as a single in early November 1963. It rose to number 12 on the UK top chart, and became the first big hit of The Rolling Stones' beginnings. It features Bill Wyman's powerful bass and Brian Jones' guitar; it is also considered one of the rare songs where backing vocals are sung by only Jones.

The Stones made the composition completely other. It was given a more upbeat arrangement, in their rough and fiery style. It was the writing of Lennon and McCartney that became inspiring for Richards and Jagger, and after that they started writing songs on their own.

So who's cooler?

The Beatles on the set of A Hard Day's Night.
The Beatles on the set of A Hard Day's Night.

Undoubtedly, both versions of the song are extremely unusual, both in their structure and creation story. Despite the fact that the Rolling Stones were a little more successful with "I Wanna Be Your Man" and spent some time in the top chart, their colleagues did not keep waiting and often performed this song not only in concerts but also on the radio. In their discography there are several versions recorded specially for the BBC, and for the Stones it was just a starting with a track.

Fans welcomed versions from both bands. For the Stones, this track was the beginning independent the writing of all subsequent hits, as well as the impetus for gaining widespread fame.

The Rolling Stones in 1965
The Rolling Stones in 1965

If listeners have responded favourably to both releases, musicians have differently were responding to the situation. John Lennon was not happy about the composition, and in a 1980 interview admitted that more successful song they certainly wouldn't share with their "rivals". However, Paul clarified in an interview that they were in the excellent relationship with The Rolling Stones, and as an author, it was a pleasure for him assist to your colleagues on the release of the single.

Keith Richards has also spoken out vs. hostility between the bands: he emphasised that the press wanted to make a show out of it, but without it the collectives' never didn't take this "rivalry" seriously.

Other covers worthy of note

The Rolling Stones
The Rolling Stones

"I Wanna Be Your Man" has been covered in a huge number of covers. A parody version of the 60s hit was presented by a pop-rock band The Barron Knights a year after the release of the Rolling Stones and Beatles versions. They imitated exactly the Stones version on their single "Call Up the Groups". However, their idea of parodying the original song was not appreciated by the publishers, and the musicians had to remake the single once again, and still it became the hereby a hit.

A cover of the song was also recorded by a punk rock band The Stooges in 2007 on their fourth studio album, The Weirdness. "I Wanna Be Your Man" became bonus track on the vinyl version of the album, which was also recorded by Iggy Pop.

'Pretty Woman With A Secret': Debbie Harry's 'Blondie' Secrets She Long Hid From Fans

Debbie Harry: facts about her personal life and career Debbie Harry is unfortunately a rarity: a surviving 78-year-old punk scene icon whose career developed during the era of...

Yuri Antonov - The Hardest Idol: Antics and Scandals That Made Producers Walk Away From the Master

Yuri Antonov: character, scandals, antics Recently, producer Sergey Lavrov said that Yuri Antonov is the most difficult, capricious and wayward maestro of the domestic variety, with whom he...

Ekaterina Batrakova: "A good half of academic musicians listen to good rock"

Ekaterina Batrakova - interview: about career and plans for the future The correspondent of Fuzz Music talked to the rock singer Katya Batrakova, whose songs have repeatedly hit the...

What does "Helter Skelter" mean, or how the Beatles wrote their most curios hit

The Beatles - Helter Skelter: song history, meaning, notoriety The Beatles were famous for their light, melodic pop-rock compositions, and therefore, no one and...

"A shy rebel and a drummer who could bang balls": the Rolling Stones' life before fame - part two

Life of The Rolling Stones before fame: Ronnie Wood, Charlie Watts, Keith Richards - part two In today's article, we continue to cover the lives of the members of the iconic band....

3.5 million people: who owns the biggest concert in history

3.5 million people - the biggest concert in music history What's cooler than a live concert? Listening to a record by your favourite artist is one thing. But...

From babes to masters of mayhem: what iconic rock bands were called at the beginning of their journey

Cult rock bands and their original names It is not without reason that they say, "What you name the ship, so it will sail". So choosing a band name is a big deal, and,...

Ches Newby is a man who was The Beatles' bass player for several gigs

The Beatles' temporary bassist Ches Newby: history and facts The Beatles are known today as "The Magnificent Liverpool Four", whose bassist, as well as ideological "engine" (along with...

Pete Townsend's first favourite band, which had a huge influence on him

Why Pete Townsend loves The Rolling Stones so much Every great musician has his or her - favourite great band. And, as a rule, getting to know them has had an...

Ronnie Wood is an admirer of the raw sound that fit perfectly with The Rolling Stones

Ronnie Wood of The Rolling Stones: biography and facts He is a member of The Rolling Stones. And for millions of people this is enough to call him a legend....

Vocals Only: What our favourite rock hits sound like without music - Part Two

Top 6 favourite rock hits with vocals only. Part Two Rock compositions that have become iconic over the years are planned as a whole work of art or performance even at the stage of writing, so...

Plant, Osbourne, Harrison - members of iconic rock bands who don't like to remember the period

Plant, Osbourne, Harrison: why these iconic rockers don't like to reminisce about their popular bands Music history remembers quite a few truly iconic rock bands - their influence...
Recommended

'Pretty Woman With A Secret': Debbie Harry's 'Blondie' Secrets She Long Hid From Fans

Debbie Harry: facts about her personal life and career Debbie Harry is unfortunately a rarity: a surviving 78-year-old punk scene icon whose career developed during the era of...

Yuri Antonov - The Hardest Idol: Antics and Scandals That Made Producers Walk Away From the Master

Yuri Antonov: character, scandals, antics Recently, producer Sergey Lavrov said that Yuri Antonov is the most difficult, capricious and wayward maestro of the domestic variety, with whom he...

Ekaterina Batrakova: "A good half of academic musicians listen to good rock"

Ekaterina Batrakova - interview: about career and plans for the future The correspondent of Fuzz Music talked to the rock singer Katya Batrakova, whose songs have repeatedly hit the...

What Lolita Milyavskaya is grateful to Pugacheva for

Lolita Milyavskaya and Alla Pugacheva: friendship, relationship, photos To call Lolita and Alla Borisovna girlfriends - somehow the language does not turn. Let the relationship between them always and...

Yuri Antonov: "Broken Zhiguli and a flat in Vykhino" - What the Artist Spent His Millions on, and How Much He's Ready to Perform for Today

Yuri Antonov: royalties, wealth, fortune Yachts, houses, business class cars... Yes, the sweet life of today's artists can only be envied, because they are literally like cheese in...

"In Her Mother's Footsteps": Olga Rozhdestvenskaya - How She Lives and Looks Today

Olga Rozhdestvenskaya: biography, career, photos and facts In the USSR there were many talented singers - with a beautiful voice, diction, manner of performance and, in fact, repertoire. How many gorgeous...

Lolita Milyavskaya: "The Motherland Betrayed Me" - 60-year-old Diva on Daughter, Love for Zelensky and Young Suitors

Lolita Milyavskaya: personal life, daughter, career, conflict with Ukraine Lolita Milyavskaya - one of the brightest divas of the national variety! And one of the most interesting persons on...

Artists Who Russians Respect and Are Ashamed of in 2023

Russia's most respected and most hated artists 2023 Over the past 2 years a lot has changed in the domestic show business. If before the beginning of the SWO the charts were dominated by such...

What's SHAMAN's Little Brother, or the PR stunt that worked: The Neverlove Story

Neverlove band: history, vocalist Yaroslav Stepanov, tracks and clips Perhaps you have already seen a video on YouTube (and by the way, it is far from one), which...